Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
Section 6 Part 2 of The White Men
Chapter 14 Greatest of Wrongs
Perhaps the greatest wrong ever f done to the Indians was the treatment received by
our tribe from the United States troops about 1863. The chief of our tribe, Mangus-Colorado,
went to make a treaty of peace for our people with the white settlement at Apache Tejo,
New Mexico. It had been reported to us that the white men in this settlement were more
friendly and more reliable than those in Arizona, that they would live up to their treaties
and would not wrong the Indians. Mangus-Colorado, with three other warriors, went to Apache
Tejo and held a council with these citizens and soldiers. They told him that if he would
come with his tribe and live near them, they would issue to him, from the Government, blankets,
flour, provisions, beef, and all manner of supplies. Our chief promised to return to
Apache Tejo within two weeks. When he came back to our settlement he assembled the whole
tribe in council. I did not believe that the people at Apache Tejo would do as they said
and therefore I opposed the plan, but it was decided that with part of the tribe Mangus-Colorado
should return to Apache Tejo and receive an issue of rations and supplies. If they were
as represented, and if these white men would keep the treaty faithfully, the remainder
of the tribe would join him and we would make our permanent home at Apache Tejo. I was to
remain in charge of that portion of the tribe which stayed in Arizona. We gave almost all
of our arms and ammunition to the party going to Apache Tejo, so that in case there should
be treachery they would be prepared for any surprise. Mangus-Colorado and about half of
our people went to New Mexico, happy that now they had found white men who would be
kind to them, and with whom they could live in peace and plenty. No word ever came to
us from them. From other sources, however, we heard that they had been treacherously
* captured and slain. In this dilemma we did not know just exactly what to do, but fearing
that the troops who had captured them would attack us, we retreated into the mountains
near Apache Pass. During the weeks that followed the departure of our people we had been in
suspense, and failing to provide more supplies, had exhausted all of our store of provisions.
This was another reason for moving camp. On this retreat, while passing through the mountains,
we discovered four men with a herd of cattle. Two of the men were in front in a buggy and
two were behind on horseback. We killed all four, but did not scalp them; they were not
warriors. We drove the cattle back into the mountains, made a camp, and began to kill
the cattle and pack the meat. Before we had finished this work we were surprised and attacked
by United States troops, who killed in all seven Indians — one warrior, three women,
and three children. The Government troops were mounted and so were we, but we were poorly
armed, having given most of our weapons to the division of our tribe that had gone to
Apache iTejo, so we fought mainly with spears, bows, and arrows. At first I had a spear,
a bow, and a few arrows; but in a short time my spear and all my arrows were gone. Once
I was surrounded, but by dodging from side to side of my horse as he ran I escaped. It
was necessary during this fight for many of the warriors to leave their horses and escape
on foot. But my horse was trained to come at call, and as soon as I reached a safe place,
if not too closely pursued, I would call him to me. During this fight we scattered in all
directions and two days later reassembled at our appointed place of rendezvous, about
fifty miles from the scene of this battle.
About ten days later the same United States troops attacked our new camp at sunrise. The
fight lasted all day, but our arrows and spears were all gone before ten o'clock, and for
the remainder of the day we had only rocks and clubs with which to fight. We could do
little damage with these weapons, and at night we moved our camp about four miles back into
the mountains where it would be hard for the cavalry to follow us. The next day our scouts,
who had been left behind to observe the movements of the soldiers, returned, saying that the
troops had gone back toward San Carlos Reservation.
A few days after this we were again attacked by another company of United States troops.
Just before this fight we had been joined by a band of Chokonen Indians under Cochise,
who took command of both divisions. We were repulsed, and decided to disband.
After we had disbanded our tribe the Bedonkohe Apaches reassembled near their old camp vainly
waiting for the return of Mangus-Colorado and our kinsmen. No tidings came save that
they had all been treacherously slain. 3 Then a council was held, and as it was believed
that MangusColorado was dead, I was elected Tribal Chief.
For a long time we had no trouble with anyone. It was more than a year after I had been made
Tribal Chief that United States troops surprised and attacked our camp. They killed seven children,
five women, and four warriors, captured all our supplies, blankets, horses, and clothing,
and destroyed our tepees. We had nothing left; winter was beginning, and it was the coldest
winter I ever knew. After the soldiers withdrew I took three warriors and trailed them. Their
trail led back toward San Carlos.
Swilling, a scout, to bring in Mangus, who had been on the warpath ever since the time
of the incident with Cochise at Bowie. The old chief was always for peace, and gladly
accepted the proffer; when he appeared at the camp General West ordered him put into
the guard-house, in which there was only a small opening in the rear and but one small
window. As the old chief entered he said: 4 This is my end. I shall never again hunt
over the mountains and through the valleys of my people.' He felt that he was to be assassinated.
The guards were given orders to shoot him if he attempted to escape. He lay down and
tried to sleep, but during the night, someone threw a large stone which struck him in the
breast. He sprang up and in his delirium the guards thought he was attempting escape and
several of them shot him; this was the end of Mangus.
“His head was severed from his body by a surgeon, and the brain taken out and weighed.
The head measured larger than that of Daniel Webster, and the brain was of corresponding
weight. The skull was sent to Washington, and is now on exhibition at the Smithsonian
CHAPTER XV
REMOVALS
WHILE returning from trailing the Government troops we saw two men, a Mexican and a white
man, and shot them off their horses. With these two horses we returned and moved our
camp. My people were suffering much and it was deemed advisable to go where we could
get more provisions. Game was scarce in our range then, and since I had been Tribal Chief
I had not asked for rations from the Government, nor did I care to do so, but we did not wish
to starve.
We had heard that Chief Victoria of the Chihenne (Oje Caliente) Apaches was holding a council
with the white men near Hot Springs in New Mexico, and that he had plenty of provisions.
We had always been on friendly terms with this tribe, and Victoria was especially kind
to my people. With the help of the two horses we had captured, to carry our sick with us,
we went to Hot Springs. We easily found Victoria and his band, and they gave us supplies for
the winter. We stayed with them for about a year, and during this stay we had perfect
peace. We had not the least trouble with Mexicans, white men, or Indians. When we had stayed
as long as we should, and had again accumulated some supplies, we decided to leave Victoria's
band. When I told him that we were going to leave he said that we should have a feast
and dance before we separated.
The festivities were held about two miles above Hot Springs, and lasted for four days.
There were about four hundred Indians at this celebration. I do not think we ever spent
a more pleasant time than upon this occasion. No one ever treated our tribe more kindly
than Victoria and his band. We are still proud to say that he and his people were our friends.
When I went to Apache Pass (Fort Bowie) I found General Howard * in command, and made
a treaty with him. This treaty lasted until long after General Howard had left our country.
He always kept his word with us and treated us as brothers. We never had so good a friend
among the United States officers as General Howard. We could have lived forever at peace
with him. If there is any pure, honest white man in the United States army, that man is
General Howard. All the Indians respect him, and even to this day frequently talk of the
happy times when General Howard was in command of our Post. After he went away he placed
an agent at Apache Pass who issued to us from the Government clothing, rations, and supplies,
as General Howard directed. When beef was issued to the Indians I got twelve steers
for my tribe, and Cochise got twelve steers for his tribe. Rations were issued about once
a month, but if we ran out we only had to ask and we were supplied. Now, as prisoners
of war in this Reservation, we do not get such good rations.
Out on the prairie away from Apache Pass a man kept a store and saloon. Some time after
General Howard went away a band of outlawed Indians killed this man, and took away many
of the supplies from his store. On the very next day after this some Indians at the Post
were drunk on "tiswin," which they had made from corn. They fought among themselves and
four of them were killed. There had been quarrels and feuds among them for some time, and after
this trouble we deemed it impossible to keep the different bands together in peace. Therefore
we separated, each leader taking his own band. Some of them went to San Carlos and some to
Old Mexico, but I took my tribe back to Hot Springs and rejoined Victoria's band.
XVI
IN PRISON AND ON THE WARPATH
SOON after we arrived in New Mexico two companies of scouts were sent from San Carlos. When
they came to Hot Springs they sent word for me and Victoria to come to town. The messengers
did not say what they wanted with us, but as they seemed friendly we thought they wanted
a council, and rode in to meet the officers. As soon as we arrived in town soldiers met
us, disarmed us, and took us both to headquarters, where we were tried by court-martial. They
asked us only a few questions and then Victoria was released and I was sentenced to the guardhouse.
Scouts conducted me to the guardhouse and put me in chains. When I asked them why they
did this they said it was because I had left Apache Pass.
I do not think that I ever belonged to those soldiers at Apache Pass, or that I should
have asked them where I might go. Our bands could no longer live in peace 1 together,
and so we had quietly withdrawn, expecting to live with Victoria's band, where we thought
we would not be molested. They also sentenced seven other Apaches to chains in the guardhouse.
I do not know why this was done, for these Indians had simply followed me from Apache
Pass to Hot Springs. If it was wrong (and I do not think it was wrong) for us to go
to Hot Springs, I alone was to blame. They asked the soldiers in charge why they were
imprisoned and chained, but received no answer.
I was kept a prisoner for four months, during which time I was transferred to San Carlos.
Then I think I had another trial, although I was not present. In fact I do not know that
I had another trial, but I was told that I had, and at any rate I was released.
After this we had no more trouble with the soldiers, but I never felt at ease any longer
at the Post. We were allowed to live above San Carlos at a place now called Geronimo.
A man whom the Indians called “Nick Golee “was agent at this place. All went well
here for a period of two years, but we were not satisfied.
In the summer of 1883 a rumor was current that the officers were again planning to imprison
our leaders. This rumor served to revive the memory of all our past wrongs — the massacre
in the tent at Apache Pass, the fate of MangusColorado, and my own unjust imprisonment, which might
easily have been death to me. Just at this time we were told that the officers wanted
us to come up the river above Geronimo to a fort (Fort Tholnas) to hold a council with
them. We did not believe that any good could come of this conference, or that there was
any need of it; so we held a council ourselves, and fearing treachery, decided to leave the
reservation. We thought it more manly to die on the warpath than to be killed in prison.
There were in all about 250 Indians, chiefly the Bedonkohe and Nedni Apaches, led by myself
and Whoa. We went through Apache Pass and just west of there had a fight with the United
States troops. In this battle we killed three soldiers and lost none.
We went on toward Old Mexico, but on the second day after this United States soldiers overtook
us about three o'clock in the afternoon and we fought until dark. The ground where we
were attacked was very rough, which was to our advantage, for the troops were compelled
to dismount in order to fight us. I do not know how many soldiers we killed, but we lost
only one warrior and three children. We had plenty of guns and ammunition at this time.
Many of the guns and much ammunition we had accumulated while living in the reservation,
and the remainder we had obtained from the White Mountain Apaches when we left the reservation.
Troops did not follow us any longer, so we went south almost to Casa Grande and camped
in the Sierra de Sahuaripa Mountains. We ranged in the mountains of Old Mexico for about a
year, then returned to San Carlos, taking with us a herd of cattle and horses.
Soon after we arrived at San Carlos the officer in charge, General Crook, took the horses
and cattle away from us. I told him that these were not white men's cattle, but belonged
to us, for we had taken them from the Mexicans during our wars. I also told him that we did
not intend to kill these animals, but that we wished to keep them and raise stock on
our range. He would not listen to me, but took the stock. I went up near Forth Apache
and General Crook ordered officers, soldiers, and scouts to see that I was arrested; if
I offered resistance they were instructed to kill me.
This information was brought to me by the Indians. When I learned of this proposed action
I left for Old Mexico, and about four hundred Indians went with me. They were the Bedonkohe,
Chokonen, and Nedni Apaches. At this time Whoa was dead, and Naiche was the only chief
with me. We went south into Sonora and camped in the mountains. Troops followed us, but
did not attack us until we were camped in the mountains west of Casa Grande. Here we
were attacked by Government Indian scouts. One boy was killed and nearly all of our women
and children were captured.
After this battle we went south of Casa Grande and made a camp, but within a few days this
camp was attacked by Mexican soldiers. We skirmished with them all day, killing a few
Mexicans, but sustaining no loss ourselves.
That night we went east into the foothills of the Sierra Madre Mountains and made another
camp. Mexican troops trailed us, and after a few days attacked our camp again. This time
the Mexicans had a very large army, and we avoided a general engagement. It is senseless
to fight when you cannot hope to win.
That night we held a council of war; our scouts had reported bands of United States and Mexican
troops at many points in the mountains. We estimated that about two thousand soldiers
were ranging these mountains seeking to capture us.
General Crook had come down into Mexico with the United States troops. They were camped
in the Sierra de Antunez Mountains. Scouts told me that General Crook wished to see me
and I went to his camp. When I arrived General Crook said to me, “Why did you leave the
reservation? “I said: “You told me that I might live in the reservation the same as
white people lived. One year I raised a crop of corn, and gathered and stored it, and the
next year I put in a crop of oats, and when the crop was almost ready to harvest, you
told your soldiers to put me in prison, and if I resisted to kill me. If I had been let
alone I would now have been in good circumstances, but instead of that you and the Mexicans are
hunting me with soldiers." He said: "I never gave any such orders; the troops at Fort Apache,
who spread this report, knew that it was untrue." Then I agreed to go back with him to San Carlos.
It was hard for me to believe him at that time. Now I know that what he said was untrue,
3 and I firmly believe that he did issue the orders for me to be put in prison, or to be
killed in case I offered resistance.
CHAPTER XVII
THE FINAL STRUGGLE
WE started with all our tribe to go with General Crook back to the United States, but I feared
treachery and decided to remain in Mexico. We were not under any guard at this time.
The United States troops marched in front and the Indians followed, and when we became
suspicious, we turned back. I do not know how far the United States army went after
myself, and some warriors turned back before we were missed, and I do not care.
I have suffered much from such unjust orders as those of General Crook. Such acts have
caused much distress to my people. I think that General Crook's death was sent by the
Almighty as a punishment for the many evil deeds he committed.
Soon General Miles was made commander of all the western posts, and troops trailed us continually.
They were led by Captain Lawton, who had good scouts. The Mexican 2 soldiers also became
more active and more numerous. We had skirmishes almost every day, and so we finally decided
to break up into small bands. With six men and four women I made for the range of mountains
near Hot Springs, New Mexico. We passed many cattle ranches, but had no trouble with the
cowboys. We killed cattle to eat whenever we were in need of food, but we frequently
suffered greatly for water. At one time we had no water for two days and nights and our
horses almost died from thirst. We ranged in the mountains of New Mexico for some time,
then thinking that perhaps the troops had left Mexico, we returned. On our return through
Old Mexico we attacked every Mexican found, even if for no other reason than to kill.
We believed they had asked the United States troops to come down to Mexico to fight us.
South of Casa Grande, near a place called by the Indians Gosoda, there was a road leading
out from the town. There was much freighting carried on by the Mexicans over this road.
Where the road ran through a mountain pass we stayed in hiding, and whenever Mexican
freighters passed we killed them, took what supplies we wanted, and destroyed the remainder.
We were reckless of our lives, because we felt that every man's hand was against us.
If we returned to the reservation we would be put in prison and killed; if we stayed
in Mexico they would continue to send soldiers to fight us; so we gave no quarter to anyone
and asked no favors.
End of Section 6
Section 7 The White Men (Part 3)
After some time we left Gosoda and soon were reunited with our tribe in the Sierra de Antunez
Mountains. Contrary to our expectations the United States soldiers had not left the mountains
in Mexico, and were soon trailing us and skirmishing with us almost every day. Four or five times
they surprised our camp. One time they surprised us about nine o'clock in the morning, and
captured all our horses 3 (nineteen in number) and secured our store of dried meats. We also
lost three Indians in this encounter. About the middle of the afternoon of the same day
we attacked them from the rear as they were passing through a prairie — killed one soldier,
but lost none ourselves. In this skirmish we recovered all our horses except three that
belonged to me. The three horses that we did not recover were the best riding horses we
had. Soon after this we made a treaty with the Mexican troops. They told us that the
United States troops were the real cause of these wars, and agreed not to fight any more
with us provided we would return to the United States. This we agreed to do, and resumed
our march, expecting to try to make a treaty with the United States soldiers and return
to Arizona. There seemed to be no other course to pursue. Soon after this scouts from Captain
Lawton's troops told us that he wished to make a treaty with us; but I knew that General
Miles was the chief of the American troops, and I decided to treat with him. We continued
to move our camp northward, and the American troops also moved northward, keeping at no
great distance from us, but not attacking us.
I sent my brother Porico (White Horse) with Mr. George Wratton on to Fort Bowie to see
General Miles, and to tell him that we wished to return to Arizona; but before these messengers
returned I met two Indian scouts — Kayitah, a Chokonen Apache, and Marteen, a Nedni Apache.
They were serving as scouts for Captain Lawton's troops. They told me that General Miles had
come and had sent them to ask me to meet him. So I went to the camp of the United States
troops to meet General Miles.
When I arrived at their camp I went directly to General Miles and told him how I had been
wronged, and that I wanted to return to the United States with my people, as we wished
to see our families, who had been captured 5 and taken away from us.
General Miles said to me: “The President of the United States has sent me to speak
to you. He has heard of your trouble with the white men, and says that if you will agree
to a few words of treaty we need have no more trouble. Geronimo, if you will agree to a
few words of treaty all will be satisfactorily arranged."
So General Miles told me how we could be brothers to each other. We raised our hands to heaven
and said that the treaty was not to be broken. We took an oath not to do any wrong to each
other or to scheme against each other.
Then he talked with me for a long time and told me what he would do for me in the future
if I would agree to the treaty. I did not greatly believe General Miles, but because
the President of the United States had sent me word I agreed to make the treaty, and to
keep it. Then I asked General Miles what the treaty would be. General Miles said to me:
6 "I will take you under Government protection; I will build you a house; I will fence you
much land; I will give you cattle, horses, mules, and farming implements. You will be
furnished with men to work the farm, for you yourself will not have to work. In the fall
I will send you blankets and clothing so that you will not suffer from cold in the winter
time.
“There is plenty of timber, water, and grass in the land to which I will send you. You
will live with your tribe and with your family. If you agree to this treaty you shall see
your family within five days."
I said to General Miles: "All the officers that have been in charge of the Indians have
talked that way, and it sounds like a story to me; I hardly believe you."
He said: “This time it is the truth."
I said: “General Miles, I do not know the laws of the white man, nor of this new country
where you are to send me, and I might break their laws."
He said: "While I live you will not be arrested."
Then I agreed to make the treaty. (Since I have been a prisoner of war I have been arrested
and placed in the guardhouse twice for drinking whisky.)
We stood between his troopers and my warriors. We placed a large stone on the blanket before
us. Our treaty was made by this stone, and it was to last until the stone should crumble
to dust; so we made the treaty, and bound each other with an oath.
I do not believe that I have ever violated that treaty; but General Miles 7 never fulfilled
his promises.
When we had made the treaty General Miles said to me: “My brother, you have in your
mind how you are going to kill men, and other thoughts of war; I want you to put that out
of your mind, and change your thoughts to peace."
Then I agreed and gave up my arms. I said: “I will quit the warpath and live at peace
hereafter."
Then General Miles swept a spot of ground clear with his hand, and said: “Your past
deeds shall be wiped out like this and you will start a new life."
CHAPTER XVIII
SURRENDER OF
ON February 11, 1887, the Senate passed the following resolution: “Resolved, That the
Secretary of War be directed to communicate to the Senate all dispatches of General Miles
referring* to the surrender of Geronimo, and all instructions given to and correspondence
with General Miles in reference to the same." These papers are published in the Senate Executive
Documents, Second Session, 49th Congress, 1886-7, Volume II, Nos. Ill to 125. For an
exhaustive account of the conditions of Geronimo's surrender the reader is referred to that document,
but this chapter is given to show briefly the terms of surrender, and corroborate, at
least in part, the statements made by Geronimo.
Upon assuming command of the Department of Arizona, General Nelson A. Miles was directed
by the War Department to use most vigorous operations for the destruction or capture
of the hostile Apaches.
The following extracts are from instructions issued April 20th, 1886, for the information
and guidance of troops serving in the southern portion of Arizona and New Mexico.
"The chief object of the troops will be to capture or destroy any band of hostile Apache
Indians found in this section of country, and to this end the most vigorous and persistent
efforts will be required of all officers and soldiers until the object is accomplished."
“A sufficient number of reliable Indians will be used as auxiliaries to discover any
signs of hostile Indians, and as trailers."
To avoid any advantage the Indians may have by a relay of horses, where a troop or squadron
commander is near the hostile Indians he will be justified in dismounting one-half of his
command and selecting the lightest and best riders to make pursuit by the most vigorous
forced marches until the strength of all the animals of his command shall have been exhausted."
The following telegrams show the efforts of the United States troops and the cooperation
of Mexican troops under Governor Torres:
“Headquarters Division of the Pacific,
“Presidio of San Francisco, Cal.
"July 22, 1886. "Adjutant General,
"Washington, D. C:
“The following telegram just received from General Miles:
“'Captain Lawton reports, through Colonel Royall, commanding at Fort Huachuca, that
his camp surprised Geronimo's camp on Yongi River, about 130 miles south and east of Campas,
Sonora, or nearly 300 miles south of Mexican boundary, capturing all the Indian property,
including hundreds of pounds of dried meat and nineteen riding animals. This is the fifth
time within three months in which the Indians have been surprised by the troops. While the
results have not been decisive, yet it has given encouragement to the troops, and has
reduced the numbers and strength of the Indians, and given them a feeling of insecurity even
in the remote and almost inaccessible mountains of Old Mexico.'
“In absence of division commander. I "C. McKeever,
"Assistant Adjutant General."
“Headquarters Division of the Pacific, “Presidio of San Francisco, Cal.
M August 19, 1886. "Adjutant General,
"Washington, D. C:
“Following received from General Miles, dated 18th:
“'Dispatches to-day from Governor Torres, dated Hermosillo, Sonora, Mexico, from Colonels
Forsyth and Beaumont, commanding Huachuca and Bowie districts, confirms the following:
Geronimo with forty Indians is endeavoring to make terms of peace with Mexican authorities
of Fronteraz district. One of our scouts, in returning to Fort Huachuca from Lawton's
command, met him, Naiche, and thirteen other Indians on their way to Fronteraz; had a long
conversation with them; they said they wanted to make peace, and looked worn and hungry.
Geronimo carried his right arm in a sling, bandaged. The splendid work of the troops
is evidently having good effect.
Should hostiles not surrender to the Mexican authorities, Lawton's command is south of
them, and Wilder, with G and M troops, Fourth Cavalry, moved south to Fronteraz, and will
be there by 20th. Lieutenant Lockett, with an effective command, will be in good position
to-morrow, near Guadalupe Canon, in Cajon Bonito Mountains. On the 11th I had a very
satisfactory interview with Governor Torres. The Mexican officials are acting in concert
with ours.'
“O. O. Howard, "Major General."
General O. O. Howard telegraphed from [Presidio, San Francisco, California, September 24, 1886,
as follows:
"... The 6th of September General Miles reports the hostile Apaches made overtures of surrender,
through Lieutenant Gatewood, to Captain Lawton. They desired certain terms and sent two messengers
to me (Miles). They were informed that they must surrender as prisoners of war to troops
in the field. They promised to surrender to me in person, and for eleven days Captain
Lawton's command moved north, Geronimo and Naiche moving parallel and frequently camping
near it. . . . At Skeleton Canon they halted, saying that they desired to see me (Miles)
before surrendering."
After Miles's arrival he reports as follows:
“Geronimo came from his mountain camp amid the rocks and said he was willing to surrender.
He was told that they could surrender as prisoners of war; that it was not the way of officers
of the Army to kill their enemies who laid down their arms."
". . . Naiche was wild and suspicious and evidently feared treachery. He knew that the
once noted leader, MangusColorado, had, years ago, been foully murdered after he had surrendered,
and the last hereditary chief of the hostile Apaches hesitated to place himself in the
hands of the palefaces. . ."
Continuing his report, General Howard says:
“. . . I believed at first from official reports that the surrender was unconditional,
except that the troops themselves would not kill the hostiles. Now, from General Miles's
dispatches and from his annual report, forwarded on the 21st instant by mail, the conditions
are plain: First, that the lives of all the Indians should be spared. Second, that they
should be sent to Fort Marion, Florida, where their tribe, including their families, had
already been ordered. . . ."
D. S. Stanley, Brigadier General, telegraphs from San Antonio, Texas, October 22, 1886,
as follows:
Geronimo and Naiche requested an interview with me when they first ascertained that they
were to leave here, and in talking to them, I told them the exact disposition that was
to be made of them. They regarded the separation of themselves from their families as a violation
of the terms of their treaty of surrender, by which they had been guaranteed, in the
most positive manner conceivable to their minds, that they should be united with their
families at Fort Marion.
“There were present at the talk they had with me Major J. P. Wright, surgeon, United
States Army; Captain J. G. Ballance, acting Judge-advocate, United States Army; George
Wratton, 1 the interpreter; Naiche, and Geronimo.
“The Indians were separated from their families at this place; the women, children, and the
two scouts were placed in a separate car before they left.
“In an interview with me they stated the following incident, which they regard as an
essential part of their treaty of surrender, and which took place at Skeleton Canon before
they had, as a band, made up their minds to surrender, and before any of them, except
perhaps Geronimo, had given up their arms, and when they were still fully able to escape
and defend themselves.
"General Miles said to them: 'You go with me to Fort Bowie and at a certain time you
will go to see your relatives in Florida.' After they went to Fort Bowie he reassured
them that they would see their relatives in Florida in four and a half or five days.
“While at Skeleton Canon General Miles said to them: ' I have come to have a talk with
you.' The conversation was interpreted from English into Spanish and from Spanish into
Apache and vice versa. The interpreting from English into Spanish was done by a man by
the name of Nelson. The interpreting from Spanish into Apache was done by Jose Maria
Yaskes. Jose Maria Montoya was also present, but he did not do any of the interpreting.
"Dr. Wood, United States Army, and Lieutenant Clay, Tenth Infantry, were present.
“General Miles drew a line on the ground and said, 'This represents the ocean,' and,
putting a small rock beside the line, he said, ‘This represents the place where Chihuahua
is with his band.' He then picked up another stone and placed it a short distance from
the first, and said, ' This represents you, Geronimo.' He then picked up a third stone
and placed it a little distance from the others, and said, ' This represents the Indians at
Camp Apache. The President wants to take you and put you with Chihuahua.' He then picked
up the stone which represented Geronimo and his band and put it beside the one which represented
Chihuahua at Fort Marion. After doing this he picked up the stone which represented the
Indians at Camp Apache and placed it beside the other two stones which represented Geronimo
and Chihuahau at Fort Marion, and said, * That is what the President wants to do, get all
of you together.'
“After their arrival at Fort Bowie General Miles said to them, ' From now on we want
to begin a new life,' and holding up one of his hands with the palm open and horizontal
he marked lines across it with the finger of the other hand and said, pointing to his
open palm, ' This represents the past; it is all covered with hollows and ridges/ then,
rubbing his other palm over it, he said, ' That represents the wiping out of the past, which
will be considered smooth and forgotten.'
“The interpreter, Wratton, says that he was present and heard this conversation.
The Indians say that Captain Thompson, Fourth Cavalry, was also present.
"Naiche said that Captain Thompson, who was the acting assistant adjutant general, Department
of Arizona, told him at his house in Fort Bowie, ' Don't be afraid; no harm shall come
to you. You will go to your friends all right.' He also told them 1 that Fort Marion is not
a very large place, and is not probably large enough for all, and that probably in six months
or so you will be put in a larger place, where you can do better.' He told them the same
thing when they took their departure in the cars from Fort Bowie.
“The idea that they had of the treaty of surrender given in this letter is forwarded
at their desire, and, while not desiring to comment on the matter, I feel compelled to
say that my knowledge of the Indian character, and the experience I have had with Indians
of all kinds, and the corroborating circumstances and facts that have been brought to my notice
in this particular case, convince me that the foregoing statement of Naiche and Geronimo
is substantially correct."
Extract from the annual report (1886) of the Division of the Pacific, commanded by Major
General O. O. Howard, U. S. Army.
Headquarters Division of the Pacific, “Presidio of San Francisco, Cal. “September 17, 1886.
"Adjutant General,
"U. S. Army, Washington, D. C: "General: I have the honor to submit the following report
upon military operations and the condition of the Division of the Pacific for the information
of the Lieutenant General, and to make some suggestions for his consideration:
“On the 17th of May, 1885, a party of about fifty of the Chiricahua prisoners, headed
by Geronimo, Naiche, and other chiefs, escaped from the White Mountain Reserve, in Arizona,
and entered upon a career of *** and robbery unparalleled in the history of Indian raids.
“Since then, and up to the time of my assuming command of this division, they had been pursued
by troops with varying success.
“After the assassination of Captain Crawford, on January 11, by the Mexicans, the hostiles
asked for a ' talk,' and finally had a conference on March 25, 26, and 27, with General Crook,
in the Canon of Los Embudos, 25 miles south of San Bernardino, Mexico, on which latter
date it was arranged that they should be conducted by Lieutenant Manus, with his battalion of
scouts, to Fort Bowie, Ariz.
“The march commenced on the morning of March 28 and proceeded until the night of the 29th,
when, becoming excited with fears of possible punishment, Geronimo Emma Tuki and Naiche,
with twenty men, fourteen women, and two boys, stampeded to the hills. Lieutenant Manus immediately
pursued, but without success.
“Simultaneously with my taking command of the division Brigadier General Crook was relieved
by Brigadier General Miles, who at once set out to complete the task commenced by his
predecessor.
“Geronimo and his band were committing depredations, now in the United States and now in Mexico,
and, being separated into small parties, easily eluded the troops, and carried on their work
of *** and outrage.
“Early in May General Miles organized the hostile field of operations into districts,
each with its command of troops, with specific instructions to guard the water holes, to
cover the entire ground by scouting parties, and give the hostiles no rest.
"An effective command, under Captain Lawton, Fourth Cavalry, was organized for a long pursuit.
“On May 3 Captain Lebo, Tenth Cavalry, had a fight with Geronimo's band 12 miles southwest
of Santa Cruz, in Mexico, with a loss of one soldier killed and one wounded. After this
fight the Indians retreated southward followed by three troops of cavalry.
“On May 12 a serious fight of Mexican troops with the hostiles near Planchos, Mexico, resulted
in a partial defeat of the Mexicans.
“On May 15 Captain Hatfield's command engaged Geronimo's band in the Corrona Mountains,
suffering a loss of two killed and three wounded, and the loss of several horses and mules,
the Indians losing several killed.
"The usual series of outrages, with fatiguing chase by troops, continued until June 21,
when the Mexicans engaged the hostiles about 40 miles southeast of Magdalena, Mexico, and
after a stubborn fight repulsed them. . . .
“About the middle of August Geronimo and his band were so reduced and harassed by the
tireless pursuit of the soldiers that they made offer of surrender to the Mexicans, but
without coming to terms.
“Their locality thus being definitely known, disposition of the troops was rapidly made
to act in conjunction with the Mexicans to intercept Geronimo and force his surrender.
“On August 25 Geronimo, when near Fronteraz, Mexico, recognizing that he was pretty well
surrounded, and being out of ammunition and food, made overtures of capitulation, through
Lieutenant Gatewood, Sixth Cavalry, to Captain Lawton.
He desired certain terms, but was informed that a surrender as prisoner of war was all
that would be accepted.
“The Indians then proceeded to the vicinity of Captain Lawton's command, near Skeleton
Canon, and sent word that they wished to see General Miles. *) “On September 3 General
Miles arrived at Lawton's camp, and on September 4 Naiche, the son of Cochise, and the hereditary
chief of the Apaches, with Geronimo surrendered all the hostiles, with the understanding,
it seems, that they should be sent out of Arizona.
“I am not informed of the exact nature of this surrender, at first deemed unconditional.
I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
“O. O. Howard, “Major General, United States Army."
Statement of W. T. Melton, Ana&arko, Oklahoma.
From 1882 to 1887 I lived in southern Arizona, and was employed by the Sansimone Cattle Company.
In 1886 I was stationed in Skeleton Canon, about 10 miles north of the boundary line
between Arizona and Old Mexico, with J. D. Prewitt. It was our duty to ride the lines
south of our range and keep the cattle of the Company from straying into Old Mexico.
One afternoon, when returning from our ride, we discovered an Indian trail leading toward
our camp. We rode hurriedly out of the hills into a broad valley so that we could better
discover any attacking parties of Apaches and if assailed have at least a fighting chance
for our lives. We knew the Apaches under Geronimo were on the warpath, but they were far down
in Old Mexico. However, our knowledge of the Indians led us to expect anything at any time
— to always be ready for the worst.
When we reached the valley we struck a cavalry trail also headed for our camp. This was perplexing,
for neither the Indians nor the soldiers seemed to have been riding fast, and both trails
led toward our camp in Skeleton Canon. This canon was a natural route from Old Mexico
to Arizona, and almost all bands of Indians, as well as detachments of United States troops,
passed and repassed through this valley when going to Old Mexico or returning therefrom,
but never before had two hostile bands passed through here at the same time and traveling
in the same direction, except when one fled and the other pursued. What this could mean
was a mystery to us. Could it be that the troops had not seen the Indians? Were the
redskins trying to head the troops off and attack them in their camp? Were the troops
hunting for those Indians? Could this be Lawton's command? Could that be Geronimo's band? No,
it was impossible. Then who were these troops and what Indians were those?
Cautiously we rode to our camp, and nailed on the door of our cabin was this notice:
BE CAREFUL, IS NEAR BY AND
HAS NOT YET SURRENDERED.
“CAPT. LAWTON."
Then we understood.
A short distance above our cabin we found the camp of the troops and we had just finished
talking with Captain Lawton, who advised us to remain in his camp rather than risk staying
alone in our cabin, when up rode the chief, Geronimo. He was mounted on a blaze-faced,
white-stockinged dun horse.
He came directly to Captain Lawton and through an interpreter asked who we were and what
we wanted.
As soon as the explanation was given he nodded his approval and rode away.
Prewitt and I rode away with him. We were well armed and well mounted and Geronimo was
well mounted, but so far as we could see unarmed. I tried to talk with the chief (in English),
but could not make him understand. Prewitt wanted to shoot 2 him and said he could easily
kill him the first shot, but I objected and succeeded in restraining him. While we were
arguing the chief rode silently between us, evidently feeling perfectly secure. All this
time we had been riding in the direction of our horses that were grazing in the valley
about a mile distant from our corral. When we came to a place about a half mile from
Lawton's camp, where a spur of the mountain ran far out into the valley, Geronimo turned
aside, saluted, said in fairly good Spanish, “Adios, Senors/' and began to ascend a mountain
path. Later we learned that he was going directly toward his camp far up among the rocks. We
rode on, drove our horses back to the corral and remained in our cabin all night, but were
not molested by the Indians.
The next day we killed three beeves for the Indians, and they were paid for by Captain
Lawton. On the second day two mounted Mexican scouts came to Lawton's camp. As soon as these
Mexicans came in sight the Indians seized their arms and vanished, as it were, among
the rocks.
Captain Lawton wrote an account of conditions and delivered it to the Mexicans, who withdrew.
After they had gone and their mission had been explained to Geronimo the Indians again
returned to their camp and laid down their arms.
On the next day word reached camp that General Miles was approaching and the Indians again
armed and disappeared among the rocks. (Many of the Apache squaws had field glasses 3 and
were stationed every day on prominent mountain peaks to keep a lookout. No one could approach
their camp or Lawton's camp without being discovered by these spies.)
Soon after General Miles joined Lawton's command Geronimo rode into camp unarmed, and dismounting
approached General Miles, shook hands with him, and then stood proudly before the officers
waiting for General Miles to begin conversation with him.
The interpreter said to Geronimo, “General Miles is your friend." Geronimo said, “I
never saw him, but I have been in need of friends. Why has he not been with me? " When
this answer was interpreted everybody laughed. After this there was no more formality and
without delay the discussion of the treaty was begun. All I remember distinctly of the
treaty is that Geronimo and his band were not to be killed, but they were to be taken
to their families.
I remember this more distinctly, because the Indians were so much pleased with this particular
one of the terms of the treaty.
Geronimo, Naiche, and a few others went on ahead with General Miles, but the main band
of Indians left under the escort of Lawton's troops.
The night before they left, a young squaw, daughter-in-law of Geronimo, gave birth to
a child. The next morning the husband, Geronimo's son, carried the child, but the mother mounted
her pony unaided and rode away unassisted — a prisoner of war under military escort.
On the afternoon of the day of the treaty Captain Lawton built a monument (about ten
feet across and six feet high) of rough stones at the spot where the treaty was made. The
next year some cowboys on a round-up camped at the place, and tore down the monument to
see what was in it.
All they found was a bottle containing a piece of paper upon which was written the names
of the officers who were with Lawton.
After the Indians left we found one hundred and fifty dollars and twenty-five cents ($150.25)
in Mexican money hidden in a rat's nest 4 near where the Indians had camped.
About ten o'clock on the morning after the Apaches and soldiers had gone away twenty
Pimos Indians, accompanied by one white man, surrounded our camp and demanded to know of
Geronimo's whereabouts. We told them of the treaty and they followed the trail on toward
Fort Bowie.
That afternoon, thinking all danger from Apaches past, my partner, Prewitt, went to ride the
lines and I was left in camp alone. I was pumping water (by horse-power) at the well,
when I saw three Indians rounding up our horses about half a mile away. They saw me but did
not disturb me, nor did I interfere with them, but as soon as they had driven that bunch
of horses northward over the hill out of sight I rode quickly off in another direction and
drove another bunch of horses into the corral. The rest of the afternoon I stayed in camp,
but saw no more Indians.
The next day we rode over the hill in the direction these Indians had gone and found
that they had camped not three miles away. There were evidently several in the party
and they had kept scouts concealed near the top of the hill to watch me, and to shoot
me from ambush had I followed them. This we knew because we saw behind some rocks at the
crest of the hill in the loose soil the imprints left by the bodies of three warriors where
they had been lying down in concealment.
At their camp we found the head and hoofs of my favorite horse, “Digger," a fine little
sorrel pony, and knew that he had served them for dinner. We followed their trail far into
Old Mexico, but did not overtake them. We had been accustomed to say "it was Geronimo's
band," whenever any depredation was committed, but this time we were not so positive.
End quote
Note by S. M. Barrett: We do not wish to express our own opinion, but to ask the reader whether,
after having had the testimony of Apaches, soldiers, and civilians, who knew the conditions
of surrender, and, after having examined carefully the testimony offered, it would be possible
to conclude that Geronimo made an unconditional surrender? Before passing from this subject
it would be well also to consider whether our Government has treated these prisoners
in strict accordance with the terms of the treaty made in Skeleton Canon.
End of Section 7 �