Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
This is the FM Gold Channel of All India Radio
in the program News Analysis now we bring you a dialogue on
Proposal to form Judicial Appointments Commission. The participants are Harmit Jain
Supreme Court advocate and Satya Prakash legal editor,
Hindustan Times. In a significant decision, Union Cabinet
On Thursday approved a constitutional amendment bill
for setting up a Judicial Appointments Commission that will replace the
Secretive system of appointment which is known as the Collegium system.
This system is in place for the last two decades.
To appoint Supreme Court and High Court judges.
This proposed commission is to replace the old system of Collegium
And not just for appointments it will also have powers of
transfer. In fact the government has been contemplating for quite some time
To bring in this kind of change but due to resistance from the judiciary
Somehow the government was dithering on this but now there appears to be
Some political consensus and that is why the government wants to go ahead with
The decision and a constitutional amendment is likely to be introduced in the
Parliament
Next week. Mr Jain tell us what is the significance of this Cabinet decision?
Basically I think that it may bring
more transparency in the appointment of of judges.
As you rightly said it was a
Secret system of Collegium till date and if we
have this judicial appointment commission which will be headed by
the Chief Justice of India along with two judges from the supreme court and
two eminent persons and Prime Minister
Law minister etc. Whatsoever may be the structure of this
Commission, but this will bring more transparency
in appointment of judges and that will strengthen the basic roots of the democracy.
Because till date if I say so that we do know
the lawyers or the other common persons
That how many seats are vacant in the High Courts or Supreme Court?
And when these judges are going to be appointed? How they will be appointed?
there is no advertisement for appointment of judges, no applications are called
no recommendations are called from the BAR associations
from High Court or the Supreme Court or any other Bar Association's
so to JCP system William bridges being decided baby
senior-most finds a user fee hike go to a place near mostar
ladies official conduct you're most afraid it is on the hardcourts really
commend the names of
any Wednesday night with of the book this Neil
put into the pit because agent can you being
what it did that's what I was explaining that duty before you see me in with your
YouTube it right
didn't mean the name of any person
who believe raised to be i what your age if he had any experience and a
age I don't forty-five then they can meet men
his name to be inside but judge to the Supreme Court
and then meeting you must for you this will be in good mood is very
they did they should be before you decide what did you talk
limited immunity to continue the board from the internet is
ID their appointment the to
and hold it system came into existence because in the post it on FB
124 already people seventeen unit with
have been put in place with judges are appointed they probably didn't don't
talk about
defended good returned after sp2
turkeys meeting between awarding the feelings of the X thirty
would be mean the system region whilst
incorporated my disapproval p.m. and there was nobody to change
equipment reported yup made yet this system has been a bit
for a lil sleepy invented only country would
appointed NBA it that the government has not been
comfortable with this system in fact the time it had been going to be a team
for quite some time put air in the system and civil law minister
don't get at kind of it took was to profit from the political
to does not the weight-for-age howdy new system
which enid and what are the benefits that will pit crew
do good yes has the same room from the worst teams in several appointments
and partners which you choose a different dude something
all those who the have been making chewing graded
this should not be a twenty this is the make it back door
for this president and there were some quantity
maybe people also lose or gain some judges will be appointed to high school
ex
sOooo this is to he did it produces through and it must be constantly
and I hope interested to be sure
Commission appointment of judges you typically
green sometimes do see eat when trying to use XD
to people who are these people in fact I'ma be view that there should be
all India duty should sleepy permission we should Feb 22 frequent
mm to the High Court where according to what you think they could be anything
that is good
penny for quite some time seventy get wanna be problems with good
system has been you said it has been the
to create a system nobody knows when somebody that has been amended
white admitted mended and it was said that
much more no major candidate for the evening
be for appointment to the High Court 48
a diversion from the paperwork do this with implode
in many cases we have incongruity late to complete but in the mid
did not benefit me for a point where that is open for dead
and then we did a board game that he's in love in several
it landed at and several other things and finally if they would drop
this seeing him did not give me the name of
lifted a piece on in it recommended home with the fam to be dedicated to the
airport
and the a he fit impeachment proceedings and friendly
here to the day what you'd be problem because he did
apart from being secretive the problem eased their
meet the new to most Rays jerseys are the supreme court will clear the name
per person to be afraid to get hurt or be
or to be related to this report yet fifty persons or even one person
he's not a believer Ortiz 1902 particular judge
he cannot be refuted he's going to be a pretty it must be unanimous
almost the majority from trendy 38
buddy who present are not in favor of a button
Sabres in that endeavor not very different
and call the spy agency's then decide
newborns the Eagles arrangement both hi would you know those who can go Diddy
in a democratic country like India regarded would I didn't get it without
asking for
any obligations when the body well we don't trust people
need conditions from the barn we don't need to thank you 1,000,000
1tb be using it because whose you
B&B because it would be to know what would be this is a distraction
what was needed because they're made dash DVD player back in the squad unit
system and actually ATP
that for only the appointment of göttingen Germany different team has to
be trusted and
good competition that BPA to see the most important that is
that have to imminent busters you have deputy
long it took part is it wouldn't that be you know publishes the five defendants
novel the first noted by the government statement
do it P it would be simple drop today what do you do if a position
from depended I don't want people me 20
was wearing it is structurally scrimmage things are going good yet he is Michael
G
density low income women questions from the so it's eighty or
the other seven persons or nine persons or aid and investment
car dealerships the BPP Music Hall
this commission what movie BBC's over 100 objects
but they're not Postmedia equity but at least he's used to being waken
weather conditions from the bar associations in the playful
before conceding for a particular person to be appointed to the High Court Judge
wouldn't be beat is work to be done structured have this commission with the
bases
many conduct debt will be morning the buckle up India
with it but does clomid clomid comes to complete the button
guilty it demanded what to look at them
wouldn't be to change because he didn't what you would do to me to me
the body does with five that this would be consulted
although hackneyed somebody predicted up the elected but
stupid at participant me know beyond that they know you
it may be better Dec 21 percent from March 12 UPI be resourceful
Stephen you know permission slip but even
motive my contingent used
dead deeper into you know almost fifteen did you know twenty
his must be pretty we must know how many feet in a particular site Ortiz
their game during the trial court it is working today then the
we're going to use the term who can apply the and
whole bean obligation or maybe could be
music is a got cannot boyden
depicted there you we waited for a bus to publication the UT committed by
persons name in the arab leaders are you go
yet so wouldn't I need only be why didn't we need the Mountain Dew India is
not a little tiny
want a pic to fit him to be but even system has been that
from bed because there are always
die would views within the coalition and that is what
desperate to appoint the number updated that supposed to mean
almost one third wicket he added included
with big *** it said your YouTube a new pool so there can be no different or
equal to North being freed up
over there are so many did have been cool
benefited and between up also
because the fact that most epic know at this wonderful
put it back in why it that
to be what hit them and the get it
whodunit him they're not I would believe a kid. to be very honest
if you see the completely stop separate windows jetties
in hardcore police looking for right from 1915
you lose some rain said more than fifty percent
candidate do not the sons and grandsons look good treating disease
for the targeted alt dear father
or something ready made it pretty good person yes soon
doctors games in read or do to lose
better trying to decide what to do 100 be
I me I can you be here in politics or
summiteers antibody movie should be moved
or TV person when do we are playing tonight we're getting the coming five
years
speed and if this works in you need about fifty
yeah the few June 20 Lord
just do so do your vision is to use must be putting review
why I this question book for European
got him system point with no but it didn't get it right
good but it completely top-rated from
they defended heroes who have been good novelty
it has been expanded going to you have to admit it but from
if fight people who cannot read to consider that
me the included finding be and
good if they didn't open pit have probably don't know how it will
but if back to the gate if it will play the political system
already expended political system in
we didn't believe these let me see those who would be wouldn't want your ***
when did you move right to use and when did you smoke going to be
any dirt road between rich and worthless like goody for you
judy is William yes we are day
that day most will be important thing to me is that hold this commission
we're doing what we do need radio sifting the judges appointed him and he
did it
holders workers that mid put his presidency
system must be open to all simulate
looked at the time it had appeared he cannot be DVD only because
know it in the world did appointed he did the
when he gets up and what did that when I get you the open road if you took my
favorite
in the appointment system if I knew you going to be in High Court Judge
I must get an opportunity so I'm be needed but I don't be
BC premier tonight of quality people
people professional very prime not good enough for you to decide to move it even
it would even be 110 I can also play Kirby
even putting I could yet where he is me
with me woman man what it means when a family trip to
it to posted but system up to open it must be transmitted
seconded make what it was good to me it wouldn't be the government
must had to pay the nickname bee who's in EE shoes
Richard becomes but being a friend printer and many
the whole great DDR like me I guess would be that
the pope that know that data but its competitor the
on the official up with the bodies and nobody would buy the book have had
little bit
political that that bill the once included
factory but by Parliament and that he should also keep in mind that didn't
mean with me
and accessories computed values between the executive and the Judiciary
because of recent some judgments on politics and politicians and
some questions about like that what do with it I don't want independence him a
public company yes
let's hope that what that is but all that concerned
what to expect but they can't get up and will hit what's the biggest to look
new development things
you are listening to a dialogue on proposal to form Judicial Appointments
Commission
the participants were I V J Supreme Court advocate
sensitive about needed editor Hindustan Times
it came to you with the program use it at ISIS produced and presented by the
new services division want to do a radio
this program for those who have it on our website new zoning out
daughter and I C dot I and you the evite opinion about this program
I Kennedy talks that GB