Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
HOW THEIR FAMILY IS MOVING
FORWARD.
THE ALL-NEW INTERVIEW TONIGHT ON
"360."
>>> NOW, THE TRAYVON MARTIN CASE
ISN'T THE ONLY ONE RAISING
ISSUES ABOUT STAND YOUR GROUND.
AN APPEALS COURT IN TAMPA SAYS
THE DEFENSE CAN EVEN BE USED ON
A SCHOOL BUS.
THE MIAMI HERALD IS REPORTING
ABOUT A STUDENT WHO WAS FOUND
GUILTY OF BATTERY.
LET'S BREAK IT DOWN.
THE BUS DRIVER TESTIFIED THAT
THE GIRL GRABBED BOY'S JACKET,
PULLED HIM ON THE SEAT AND
PUNCHED HIM.
THE GIRL, BY THE WAY, DISPUTED
THE CLAIM.
WE'RE NOT SURE IF SHE NATIONED
ANY CHARGES.
BUT THE BOY DID FIGHT BACK.
THE CASE WENT TO COURT.
THE ZWLUCH BLOCKED USAGE OF
STAND YOUR GROUND.
THE BOY APPEALED.
AND NOW JOINING US, DANNY
CEVALLOS AND ATTORNEY AND FORMER
CRIMINAL PROSECUTOR FAITH
JENKINS.
THANK YOU BOTH FOR BEING HERE.
LET'S TALK ABOUT THIS NOTION,
SHOULD STAND YOUR GROUND APPLY
IN A SCHOOL BUS FIGHT?
NOT JUST THE NOTION THE FACT
IT'S HAPPENING ON A SCHOOL BUS,
A SCHOOL BUS FIGHT, THOSE THINGS
HAPPEN LIKELY DAILY AROUND THE
COUNTRY.
FAITH, LET'S START WITH YOU?
>> WELL, IN FLORIDA, THE STATUTE
IS VERY BROAD.
ANYONE CAN INVOKE STAND YOUR
GROUND DEFENSE IF THEY'RE IN A
PLACE WHERE LEGALLY ENTITLED TO
BE.
THE LOWER COURT FOUND THE
STATUTE ONLY APPLIED IF YOU WERE
IN YOUR HOME OR CAR.
THE HIGHER COURT RECOGNIZED THAT
AND THAT'S WHY THE DECISION WAS
REVERSED.
IT DOESN'T MATTER IF YOU'RE A
SCHOOL BUS OR STREET CORNER.
UNDER FLORIDA STATUTE, IF YOU'RE
LEGALLY ENTITLED TO BE WHERE YOU
ARE, YOU CAN INVOKE STAND YOUR
GROUND.
>> DANNY, YOU PROBABLY HAD ONE
OF THOSE FIGHTS ON A SCHOOL BUS
GROWING UP?
>> OH, I WAS THE RECIPIENT OF
MANY BEATINGS ON A SCHOOL BUSS
UNFORTUNATELY.
THE THING TO UNDERSTAND ABOUT
STANDARD GROUND, THE STATUTE
CREATES A PRESUMPTION IN CERTAIN
AREAS.
IN OTHER WORDS, IF YOU'RE IN
YOUR HOME OR IN YOUR CAR, OH
WHAT A DIFFERENCE GEORGE
ZIMMERMAN BEEN IN HIS CAR WHEN
THIS ALTERCATION STARTED THIS
CASE MAY HAVE NEVER MADE IT TO
TRIAL.
SO IT CREATES A PRESUMPTION THAT
THE USING OF FORCE IS PROPER.
ANYWHERE ELSE, THE DEFENDANT HAS
TO PROVE IT.
SO FAITH IS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.
IT DOESN'T MATTER, YOU CAN BE IN
A SCHOOL BUS.
YOU CAN BE IN A PARK.
UP CAN BE EATING GREEN EGGS AND
HAM, WHEREVER YOU ARE, YOU MAY
BE ABLE TO APPLY STAND YOUR
GROUND AS A DEFENSE.
THERE NO -- THERE IS NO
GUARANTEE THAT IF YOU'RE IN YOUR
HOME OR CAR IT APPLIES.
BUT THERE SAY STATUTORY
PRESUMPTION.
ONCE GET OUTSIDE THAT LOCUST, AS
LONG AS YOU'RE SOMEWHERE YOU'RE
LAWFULLY ALLOWED TO BE IT IS
BROAD IN FLORIDA.
IF YOU CAN PROVE IT,
PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE
YOU INVOKE STAND YOUR GROUND
IMMUNITY.
>> I'M CONCERNED, I WANT TO PUT
THIS QUESTION TO BOTH OF YOU,
THIS IS ABOUT -- YOU KNOW, WHAT
KIND OF MESSAGE IS THIS SENDING
TO OUR KIDS AND TEENS?
>> WELL THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
STAND YOUR GROUND AND REGULAR
DEFENSE LAWS IS THERE'S NO DUTY
TO RETREAT.
YOU DON'T HAVE TO STAND DOWN.
YOU DON'T HAVE TO COUNT TO TEN.
THERE'S NO OBLIGATION TO TRY TO
QUELL A DISPUTE.
YOU CAN USE FORCE IN THE
BEGINNING.
AND IT TAKES AWAY THAT CHOICE,
THAT LIMITATION, AND THAT
MESSAGE THAT WE WANT TO SEND TO
OUR KIDS.
IF YOU DON'T WANT TO RESORT TO
VIOLENCE DON'T.
BUT THE STAND YOUR GROUND
STATUTE SAYS JUST THE OPPOSITE.
YOU HAVE THAT OPTION, YOU CAN
TAKE IT AND YOU'RE NOT GOING TO
BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE IF YOU
ACTUALLY HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO
RETREAT AND YOU DIDN'T.
>> DANNY FINAL THOUGHT?
>> YEAH, WHEN APPLIED, THERE
WON'T BE THAT MANY DIFFERENCES
BETWEEN SELF-DEFENSE AND STAND
YOUR GROUND.
THE REAL CRITICISM IS STAND YOUR
GROUND AS A POLICY.
WHAT EFFECT, WHAT INCENTIVES IT
CREATES.
THAT'S THE REAL CRITICISM ON A