Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
sharks positive hard-hit his campaign director for a free press
uh... they've been at absolute forefront verified ng
for net neutrality today with decision on that date rally by the f_c_c_ is a
three to decision one bring tem on here for some analysis wilma shipped him
okay
great-great sal's sourcing we should use
break it down tell us the different parts of this decision
and what it means
i think we repeat that question
yes you summarize alliance with the different parts of this decision
for wireless lan lines etcetera
what they decide
well what appetite bs cc
voted on a roll
that they are now calling that neutrality which is nothing of the
shortened and the reason that we don't think that many county
because it did not work
and came ashore about their neutrality equal protection
to wireless
realm mobile internet
bat we expect
hum and they're pretty picture splitting the internet into two
and looking at
the white light internet at one point uh... one point of access in the wild
figure that has another
and they're allowing the carrier due to all sorts of discriminatory practices
in the lilac
a that we need
uh... prompting kilometer after what we saw today was just a classic case
regulatory capture with the chairman
that the other cc
where basically negotiating on behalf of eighteen p
and comcast international cable telecommunication association try it
to craft a compromise and it worked will mark the capitulation capri dropped a
lot of that
the fundamental
entered openness we expect
and tremendous out it will
now before we get into the the capitulation and why they did that
ino i want a little bit more detail on both sides this
so deeper for orders verbs that do we have met the trolley
for landlines
or or essar loopholes in that as well let's start with a
without me we don't have any crowding in any respect rapid three it before this
so we'll revolt
with loopholes with with languages with language
regarding with call pannu you know reasonable management of network in
allowances for special services
it also are redundant
shaky legal foundation we have been pushing
the f_c_c_ to resource
it's a story of a thought that the political idle hero
and what the chairman tried to do here were scrapped the rule
under title one authority the overreacted it's a very of the
communications act a very very shaky legal wedding
they created some very convoluted scenario by which
they would have any power to enforce
what's what
standards that they wear are putting into virtual but
so if it is
little with so many loophole that it allows
declared an internet service providers to create sort so it's a specialized
services
that plane comment called the pink prior to patients the film
whether couple companies can pay for special access
do end users
angelito a level playing field in a way
that fundamental and about the open are set yourself on the lilac space very bad
were were very concerned about that because increasingly
people while using wireless mobile but i think that the first point of access
brought them
this is that that percentage of people
in low-income communities incommunicado
that are going on the floor and that's what if we want to make sure the equal
protection fair
but overall across all internet access point blog
the core of people report
so that i repeat can't create
special actually says
cartwright
some of the products over other company most of the ashby that you know dot
would look at the providing video services
and the business of providing conservatives
though they haven't economic him
sensitive to discriminate against other competitors
that offering online
so that the
and photos upload a major concerns
one sufficiently at last
in the order that was passed by a three to majority thing fights and i want to
diamond louise one more time here
and i think that these a-sixes serve credibly important how things the wind
up playing out
when you talk about basically the reasonable management loophole
does that mean that the that companies can decide
to charge more or less that
based on their reasonable management and then the f_c_c_ if they find it
unreasonable would have to overrule them
or isn't that assumption
that the have to charge the same on land mines
the end it would have to seek an exemption
from the f_c_c_
to do anything different
power well built the way that yet out there in fact that the batting order but
i am
is a crime and welfare reasonable
management guideline if they have to go somebody have to make a complaint the
ecpi
and they have to go but i think that the visionary determine that'd work
hopefully what will happen with any of these complaints
that we expect the i_p_ charge a fee
feasibility
he didn't even get a complaint import
avnet though so it's really deflected to consider whether to file a complaint
the f_e_c_ then go through a process where they because if you take that
you'll be the highest even invited it or did mention the fact that they fully
intend to challenge
the f_t_c_'s authority inequality
uh... it in court and then i realized that there was a court challenge that
happen
that in two thousand and two thousand island comcast county deputies
ability to sanction them purple opti naturopathic alternative netcore that
challenge
bilaterally with her out in court the in the a federal appeals court earlier this
year with a further two black if you ask the
the legal authority ever thought under title one pops vacation you know that
the f_t_c_ today said that that day
they think they have a legal authority
thunder title one for the poor expectation here
with its week ruling that is the moment
any of these readable network management stuff challenges go before the f_t_c_
you're going to be another court battle and get the throw it out again applied
we said that you have to be right base while you have to restore
the f_e_c_ spoke forty under title co
that these kinds of discriminatory practices
uh... are
are
sanction
by very clear authority on the vital to which is part of the twenty fifth
blank documentation back
fairly clear very clearly
atlases
the f_e_c_
story to serve as a watchdog over over over the internet
so when we look back at the bigger picture now
a lot of some people in washington are saying that
hey listen now the republicans aren't happy with this and verizon congress' so
they're not happy with this
because they want to do bility to be able to charge whatever they want
uh... so they had a compromise and the democrats some other democrats like
yourself
on happy with it because you didn't get everything you wanted
well look it's a compromise so suck it up
but is that fair
no i this is not a proper michael let capitulation
we have we have
we have a map of squandered opportunity here
we've got a majority vote at at the f_c_c_ in favor of mini-trial
neutrality year we had a
we had a president woodbury outspoken in support of net neutrality made a
campaign promises and several pledges
while in office to get the
done
uh... we we are organization prepress workers
there's mood like move on and purple kian credo
delivered-to million public comment the f_c_c_ so there was
clearly public intensive
in the public comment profit from the the f_t_c_
it would have the red cross
laid out before it to make this rule
they had political coverage they have popped
popular support
they have they have the support allegedly even a president obama at
least rhetorically
and the only thing that committed very
power for the world mobilized
boating table lobbying this with us
squandered opportunity
chairman really really blew it
uh... and we are now back
to ground zero back to the starting point where we have a very very unclear
protection for net neutrality and we have
increasingly on its feet moving into a case
where they want to charge extra for procured services where they want that
discriminates against products of on my product they don't like the complete
with their own
and we really we needed a decisive action here that was
this was nothing close to a compromise intimate with the demming that had beat
the chairman is trying to paint it as such
but if you look at at some of the the organization for the speakers
definition a lot of them are descriptions are supported by the phone
cable company
there really isn't about dates
confront this around that
any respect and and and
and he could have done certainly done a lot better
tim when we go to an even broader picture
wit when you look it and
what happened here what will you said overwhelming popular support political
cover
the president said he was going to is that you are add all this up
and yet the company's
still won
d use it on for some late in the ingi engender a certain degree of
hopelessness
that no matter what you do
rename one million signature alanna two million right
the matter what you do it doesn't matter
the large corporations in republican president democratic present it doesn't
matter
the big corporations are going to win no matter what
well you know
anything in washington the sorts of things take a great deal of time to take
a great deal of organizing this event
authored a relatively new ish
issue banana kelly debate
there's only been around for about four five years ago and you know we are
hoping with this president we're hoping with bc
that we would we would get these rules and i'd like to get these protections
back into place you have the open internet protected
as it with the julie intended to be now we're looking at a campaign that's going
to stretch out over over several years we have a congress
coming then again you were eight
that uh... eyes that were refill
uh... a_t_t_
as heavily lobbied descriptive
that that the net new members of congress to take
taken terrible bouts of campaign contributions from eighteen t
so if we're going to win on that
you know we've your grip rear
birth in progress technical long-time bear the chapter would do it on the
report
we're going to fight that fight there the chance that we can win on the top
where at the f_t_c_ they're still looking at weather dot reclassify
brought down their title through that the fight worth fighting
berlet so there is there a lot of things we can do
but but i would be lying to you if i didn't say that today with a major
setback
yet demonization deal and i i don't want to make people hopeless and i don't
believe that i think
than that
long-run wearing to change the system
aunt so that
the corporations don't have the kind of how they have now
but and you go to a course that make sense you've got a better shot there
it's other although corporations are also taking over the courts
as you see with the new york times are great piece about that
about how the robbers court has been incredibly pro-business right
and a back up with facts that and numbers and statistics
base on a number of times irb ruled in favor of business interests
all that being said i mean
in congress every allison
i mean you *** if you can't do it under a president who
actually said he would do it
an f_c_c_ commissioner www absolutely said he would do it when you have a
quick
all the popular opinion on your side
they're never going to do it meant they're never going to do it the way
that this system is structured now
billboard corporate org
always wear
well never reported that the bigger bright record
let me tell you the people of a larger picture
inexorable fixer about fifty we have to change campaign finance issues
we have to uh... we have to figure out how alka refers to the
the united decision
uh... we have to reform the media i wouldn't protect that neutrality at the
part of a larger picture
a larger better democracy movement i think they are
there's a lot of frustration in there that could be capped a new book on the
left and the right there at the beijing
on how many ish premonition there's common ground for example between
between progress is uneven even the key part and i think that the challenge
organizer such as we've got another doctor
try to figure out
with a common ground is try to tap into that general frustration with the way
are the market on truth right now
and movie ferret battled for work in concert with no this is a real challenge
but a lot of erica market moving to try to figure that out
try to fix the system which is which is
if you fail to still crop
at its very foundations that
but you know that
but the fight worth fighting and and you know i hope we can
weekend with we can't have a happier days and today in the future that him
i'll ask you a little of my opinion on that
all these other it all these issues will lose all
that because as long as the system is set up as it is
but we have no chance he has the power of that kind of money right
and little people in power mme dot anything but that kind of money
and
we bought the bed together
actually change the system
if we don't take away the power of corporate money
with all of these campaigns whether it's you aren't on that you tried a
whether it's health care whether it's financial reform
we're all going to get slaughtered birthday
so i i think we had to a whole different thing where we've been together
and actually throw a monkey wrench into the middle of the system
although i split the whole countries and massive trouble now having said that we
agree on that final thing for you
you know this is custom debate about obama is he doing the best he can and
he's doing incremental work
and eventually that will lead to better results and
people are being impatient
or now he's just doing the same thing that any prose that was fun
person would do and go along with the the corporations of senator
at with this decision
you fall
firmly on one side or
all right
it at all
that would be difficult one for because you know we really really work hard
within the election the election year
expand end bit there early it taped at this
administration
annexure that this message out he was a primary issue and he came out was report
force former
on the election travel when he is really cute
internet mtech polity platform
nearly two thousand i'm here that you kelly topped the list
uh... i think yak
president
as
yukio hit one of the couple of victory or even consider them victory for the
last week
though it's a shame that your product picnic neutrality at the victory because
it's nothing at the port
it makes me suspicious of all the other victory frame theory makes because
it wiped out from that would fit the patrol
through the net neutrality victory i think we have reason to be suspicious
that this president isn't being poliana
when he speaks
true reform
because what happened at the apt
she witnessed with nothing
of the tort it was regulatory capture it was a h airmen that were with merely
trying to appease
most powerful corporate interests
and who completely for abdicated his responsibility
he's a politician the loves to hang mission accomplished signs
anne is a willing accomplice in the media articles i read on it today say
that it was major reform of the f_c_c_ in favor of that betrayal
so well there you go there you go i'm in once you and where they call health care
reform major reform restore perform
wants reform same thing historic major hang the banner
so who are in a world in trouble man
and i'll tell you
if my last comment on it is that i am to the audience look i know how hard free
press work
i don't know any
advocacy group on any issue that work harder to give you guys credit
and that's why today and on this issue is so dispirited because if you guys
couldn't do it and looked at eight canon healthcare did i was dubious about where
the money was going to coming from what their interest for its own you guys are
the real deal right and you worked as hard as you possibly could and you light
up all the docs you didn't do anything wrong you cross turkeys u dot on your
eyes and you lost anyway
that's why attorney in so many ways
this that you know if this is an evidence enough for people
that the system is broken i don't know what it's going to take a mess
weapon correct you know we've got a bit or you could be a trippy
the f_e_c_ chairman pain at the picturing it
innes africa point unit that the paint himself as a reasonable moderate your
honor
when we represent the voices of millions of americans have been active on the big
deal
and they have a karen faith
at the public outcry in this
represent in extremis
you with us
profound disappointment
that's what they do when you hear moderate run for the hills doesn't mean
moderate all
tim represents the moderates 'cause the that's what a great majority of the
country believes we all believe in that it rally ok right wing left-wing doesn't
matter we all want the same freedom on the internet ok when they say mater they
don't mean modern they mean corporates they mean uh... a_t_p_ rising comcast
have agreed to it
so unfortunately watch that works
tim keep your head up
will band together and will fight the susmita don't work
will get on a project